...
NHS Employment Income
By Tax Accountant Editorial Team

Why a Second NHS Employment Can Create a Tax Underpayment

A second NHS employment can look harmless from a tax point of view. The doctor is still working for the NHS. The income is still processed through payroll. Tax is usually deducted before the money reaches...

NHS Employment Income
Tax guidance should be applied to the facts. This article gives general UK tax information for doctors and medical professionals. Your own tax position may depend on records, income sources, pension figures, residence status, HMRC deadlines and previous filings.

A second NHS employment can look harmless from a tax point of view. The doctor is still working for the NHS. The income is still processed through payroll. Tax is usually deducted before the money reaches the bank.

However, PAYE is only as accurate as the information held by HMRC and the payroll teams involved.

If a doctor has two NHS employments, each employer may operate a separate tax code. The wrong split of allowances, or the wrong second-job tax code, can lead to too little tax being deducted during the year.

The underpayment may only appear later, when HMRC issues a tax calculation or when the Self Assessment return is prepared.

How a second employment happens

For doctors, a second NHS employment can arise in several ways. It may be a substantive post with one trust and bank work with another. It may be a training rotation where an old employment remains open on HMRC’s records. It may be a part-time role alongside another NHS contract.

Sometimes the doctor does not think of it as a second employment because both roles are connected to the NHS.

For PAYE, the employer record matters. If there are two payrolls, HMRC may treat them as separate employments.

Why the tax code can be wrong

HMRC explains in its guidance on tax codes that a tax code is used by an employer or pension provider to work out how much Income Tax to deduct. It also confirms that a person can have a tax code for each employment or pension.

This is where the issue begins.

A doctor’s main employment may use the personal allowance. A second employment may use a BR, D0 or D1 code. GOV.UK’s guidance on how tax works if you have more than one job explains that these codes may apply to second jobs or pensions depending on total income.

If the doctor is a higher-rate taxpayer but the second employment uses a basic-rate code, too little tax may be deducted.

Why NHS doctors are more exposed

Doctors often have variable pay. Overtime, on-call payments, weekend work, bank shifts, pay awards and arrears can all change taxable income.

A second employment may be small at first. Later, it may increase. HMRC’s estimate may not catch up quickly.

This can create an underpayment even though both employers have deducted tax through payroll.

The problem is not that payroll ignored tax. The problem is that payroll may not know the doctor’s total income across all employments.

First payslip checks

The first payslip from the second employment should be checked carefully.

The tax code is the starting point. The doctor should also check taxable pay, tax deducted, National Insurance, pension deductions, student loan deductions and year-to-date figures.

If the code is BR, D0 or D1, it may be right. It may also be wrong. The correct code depends on total income, not on whether the job is labelled “main” or “secondary”.

If the code is 1257L on a second employment while the main job also uses the personal allowance, that should be reviewed quickly.

When HMRC may collect the underpayment

If too little tax is deducted, HMRC may collect the underpayment later.

This can happen through a P800 calculation, a Simple Assessment, a later PAYE code adjustment or the Self Assessment return.

A doctor may then feel HMRC has created a new tax bill. In reality, the tax may relate to income already received, but taxed at too low a rate during the year.

This is why early checking is important.

For doctor-specific PAYE support, see PAYE Tax Code Review for Doctors.

Second employment and Self Assessment

A second NHS employment does not automatically mean a tax return is required.

However, it can contribute to a wider Self Assessment need where the doctor has private practice income, locum income, rental income, pension annual allowance issues, foreign income or professional expense claims.

A doctor already filing a tax return should make sure both employments are included. The P60s and P45s should be checked against HMRC records before submission.

For wider help, see Self Assessment Tax Returns for Doctors.

Practical example

A doctor has a main NHS employment taxed under code 1257L. The doctor then starts bank shifts through another NHS payroll. The second employment uses BR, so tax is deducted at 20%.

By the end of the year, the doctor’s total income is well within the higher-rate band. Some of the bank income should have been taxed at 40%.

HMRC later calculates an underpayment.

The second payroll did deduct tax. It just did not deduct enough for the doctor’s total income.

What doctors should keep

Doctors should keep payslips from each employer, P60s, P45s, HMRC tax code notices and any HMRC online tax account updates. These records help show whether the employment income and tax deducted have been reported correctly.

If the doctor has pension annual allowance issues, the payroll records should also be kept with pension statements.

Key point for doctors

A second NHS employment can create an underpayment even where tax is deducted through PAYE.

The risk is higher where the second role uses the wrong tax code, the doctor’s income changes, or HMRC holds incomplete employer records.

Doctors should check the first payslip from any second NHS employment and compare the tax code with total expected income.

Disclaimer

This article is general guidance for doctors and medical professionals. It is not personal tax advice. The correct position depends on your tax codes, total income, employer records, PAYE deductions, Self Assessment status and wider circumstances.