What doctors should do after receiving an HMRC simple assessment
The letter headed PA302 gives a doctor two deadlines at once: 60 days to challenge the figures and, in most cases, 31 January to pay. It is an HMRC simple assessment, a tax bill for an...
The letter headed PA302 gives a doctor two deadlines at once: 60 days to challenge the figures and, in most cases, 31 January to pay. It is an HMRC simple assessment, a tax bill for an earlier year that HMRC has calculated itself from information supplied by employers and banks. There is no return to complete. The task is to check the calculation against the doctor’s own records, query anything that is wrong, and pay what is correctly due.
Doctors who have never had dealings with HMRC beyond their payslip are often surprised to receive one. In most cases nothing has been done wrong. PAYE, the system that deducts tax from salary, works well for one job with steady pay. It works less well for a career that involves several employers in a year, extra shifts paid through a separate payroll, and savings that have grown with seniority.
A simple assessment is also not always right. HMRC builds it from data that may be incomplete, duplicated or out of date. Paying it unchecked is as much a mistake as ignoring it.
Why a doctor receives an HMRC simple assessment
HMRC issues a simple assessment when a person has not paid enough tax for a year and the shortfall cannot be collected by adjusting their tax code. The stated reasons include owing £3,000 or more, and having untaxed income such as savings interest or dividends. They are listed in the government’s guide to understanding a Simple Assessment tax bill.
For doctors, four causes account for most cases. Changing trust during the year can leave two payrolls each giving the full tax-free allowance for a time. Bank or locum shifts paid through a separate payroll are often taxed at 20% when 40% is due. Savings interest above the £500 allowance for higher-rate taxpayers is reported to HMRC by banks but not taxed at source. And once income passes £100,000, the personal allowance is withdrawn, which a tax code does not always reflect.
Smaller underpayments are normally collected by reducing the following year’s tax code. A simple assessment tends to arrive when the amount is too large for that.
How to check the calculation
The letter shows the income HMRC has used, the tax already deducted, and the balance due. Each figure should be compared with a document the doctor holds.
Employment income and tax paid
Pay and tax from every employer in the year should match the P60, or the P45 from a job that ended. A doctor who rotated between trusts needs one for each. Two errors are common: an employment appearing twice, and a short post being missed altogether. The taxable pay on a P60 is already reduced by NHS pension contributions, so the figure on the assessment should be the lower one, not gross salary.
Savings interest
Interest should match the bank’s annual statements. Interest from an ISA is tax-free and should not appear at all. Interest on a joint account belongs half to each holder unless the shares are different. A fixed-term bond can pay several years of interest in one tax year, which may be correct but is worth confirming.
Reliefs that are missing
HMRC can only include reliefs it knows about. Professional subscriptions, such as GMC and royal college fees, reduce taxable income if they have been claimed. Gift Aid donations and personal pension contributions extend the basic-rate band for a higher-rate taxpayer. If these were never reported, the bill will be too high.
Consider a consultant billed £3,200. The calculation includes £1,600 because her allowance was reduced at income of £108,000, £1,000 on £2,500 of taxable interest, and £600 underpaid on shifts through a second payroll. On checking, £900 of the interest came from an ISA. Removing it reduces the bill by £360.
Challenging the figures within 60 days
A doctor who thinks any amount is wrong must call or write to HMRC within 60 days of the date on the letter. HMRC needs to be told which figures are incorrect, what they should be, and which records were used to check. It may ask to see those records. The process is described in HMRC’s guidance on what to do if the amounts are wrong.
If HMRC agrees, it issues a new simple assessment. If it disagrees, it sends a decision letter with its reasons, and the doctor then has 30 days from the date of that letter to appeal.
A query does not pause the payment date. The tax must still be paid by the deadline unless HMRC confirms that it will delay it. Where a revised assessment follows, the latest letter shows the total for the year, and only the difference from what has already been paid is due.
When and how to pay
For the 2025/26 tax year, a letter issued before 31 October 2026 must be paid by 31 January 2027. A letter issued on or after that date must be paid within three months of the date on it. The amount can be paid in one sum or in several smaller payments, provided the full balance is cleared by the deadline. The options are set out on the government’s page for paying a Simple Assessment bill.
Each letter carries a 14-character payment reference beginning with X. Using the wrong reference can send the payment to a different tax account. Interest is charged on tax paid late, currently at 8% a year, and a doctor who cannot pay in time should contact HMRC before the deadline, not after it.
Doctors who should be filing a return instead
A simple assessment only covers income HMRC already knows about. It does not deal with private practice fees, self-employed locum income, rent, or an annual allowance charge on NHS pension growth. A doctor with any of these needs to file a Self Assessment return for the year.
In that situation the doctor should contact HMRC, explain that a return will be filed, and ask for the simple assessment to be withdrawn. Otherwise the same year can end up assessed twice. Paying the simple assessment does not satisfy the duty to declare other income.
Treat the bill as a prompt to fix the tax code
A simple assessment collects last year’s shortfall. It does nothing to stop the same shortfall arising this year. If the cause was a second payroll, growing savings interest or a reduced personal allowance, the current tax code is probably still wrong.
Once the bill is settled, a tax code review should follow. Telling HMRC about expected interest, additional employments and income over £100,000 allows the code to collect the right amount each month. A doctor should keep the assessment letter, the P60s and bank statements used to check it, and a note of any call to HMRC with the date and the name of the adviser spoken to.
This article is general information based on UK tax rules at November 2026 and is not advice on individual circumstances. Professional advice should be taken before acting.