Private patient fee collection and patient lists: tax control points
Good private patient fee collection means every consultation and procedure reaches your tax return once, in the right year and at the gross amount. For 2026/27, most self-employed doctors are taxed on fees when the money...
Good private patient fee collection means every consultation and procedure reaches your tax return once, in the right year and at the gross amount. For 2026/27, most self-employed doctors are taxed on fees when the money arrives. The controls that matter are the ones that tie your patient list to your invoices, and your invoices to your bank.
That sounds like administration, and it is usually left to a medical secretary or a billing company. The tax return, though, carries the doctor’s signature. When the turnover figure is wrong, the cause is rarely dishonesty. It is a gap between three records that nobody has compared: who was seen, what was billed and what was paid.
This article works through the points where private fee income most often goes astray, and what a sound system looks like at each one.
Which tax year does a private fee belong to?
Cash basis, which counts income when it is received and costs when they are paid, is now the standard method for sole traders and partnerships. It has been the default since 2024/25. A doctor who prefers traditional accounting, where income is counted when the work is invoiced, has to opt out on the tax return.
The difference shows at the year end. Suppose you invoice an insurer on 20 March 2027 and the money arrives on 28 April 2027. On the cash basis the fee belongs to 2027/28. On traditional accounting it belongs to 2026/27, even though you have not been paid.
Either method is acceptable. What causes trouble is a mixture, where some fees are counted when billed and others when banked. A fee can then be taxed twice or missed altogether. Decide which basis you use, tell whoever keeps your books, and apply it to every fee.
Control point one: does the patient list match the invoices?
Start from clinical activity, not from the bank statement. Your clinic lists, theatre lists and the private hospital’s own activity reports show who was treated. Each entry should lead to one of three outcomes: an invoice, a recorded decision not to charge, or a note that the hospital billed the episode as part of a package.
A monthly comparison catches two different problems. The first is work never billed, which is lost income. The second is income with no invoice behind it, such as a patient who pays an excess by card at the clinic desk. That money is taxable whether or not paperwork exists, because every form of payment counts, including cash, card and cheque.
The list kept for tax purposes needs very little: a patient reference, the date, the service and the fee. Clinical detail does not belong in the accounting record.
Control point two: insurer remittances and patient shortfalls
An insurer often settles several patients in one payment, after deducting excesses and shortfalls. If the lump sum is posted to “fees” without being allocated to individual invoices, the unpaid balances become invisible. The shortfall is still owed by the patient, and someone has to chase it or decide to write it off.
How an unpaid fee is treated depends on your accounting basis. On the cash basis, a fee that never arrives was never taxed, so there is nothing to claim. On traditional accounting, the fee was taxed when invoiced, and relief is due only once that particular debt is shown to be irrecoverable, under section 35 of ITTOIA 2005. A general allowance for “doubtful fees” is not deductible.
How should refunds and written-off fees be recorded?
A refund to a patient or insurer reduces income in the period it is paid. Record it against the original invoice, so the reason can be shown later. For a fee you decide not to pursue, note the date and the reason. A list of old balances with no decisions against it is the weakest part of most private practice ledgers.
Control point three: billing companies and gross fees
A billing company collects fees, deducts its commission and pays you the balance. Your income is the gross amount collected. The commission is an expense.
Take a consultant whose agent collects £180,000 in the year and charges 3%. The commission is £5,400 and £174,600 reaches the bank. The correct entries are turnover of £180,000 and an expense of £5,400. A common error is to report the £174,600 banked as turnover and then claim the £5,400 again as a cost. That understates profit by £5,400, which is £2,430 of income tax at the 45% rate, before National Insurance.
Ask the agent for a statement drawn up to 5 April, or to your accounting date, and use the same cut-off every year. The statement, not your bank feed, is the record that shows what was collected for you and what was deducted.
Private patient fee collection under Making Tax Digital
Making Tax Digital for Income Tax has applied since 6 April 2026 to people whose gross self-employment and property income together exceeds £50,000. The threshold falls to £30,000 from April 2027. Most consultants with a private list are already within it.
The rules require digital records and a summary of income and expenses sent to HMRC every quarter. A fee ledger rebuilt from bank statements each January no longer works. Your billing system has to feed figures into compatible software during the year, and the reconciliations described above have to be done at least quarterly.
Keep the underlying records for at least five years after the 31 January filing deadline for the year. That includes agent statements, insurer remittance advices and the working papers that tie them together. We look at the wider accounting picture on our page about private practice tax for doctors.
Where the three records have to agree
The test of a fee system is simple to state. Pick any patient episode and trace it from the clinic list to an invoice, and from the invoice to a receipt, a refund or a write-off decision. Then pick any receipt in the bank and trace it back the other way. If both journeys can be completed without guesswork, the turnover figure on the return will stand up.
Insurers and private hospitals keep their own records of what they paid you, and HMRC has powers to ask third parties for information. A turnover figure that cannot be reconciled to those records is hard to defend, even where the difference is an innocent timing point.
The judgement that remains is yours: which fees to pursue, when to write one off, and who signs off the quarterly figures. Those decisions should be visible in the records and made by you, not left to accumulate in a spreadsheet. A set of GP and consultant accounts is only as reliable as the fee ledger underneath it.
This article is general information for doctors and is not advice on your individual circumstances. Tax rules change and depend on the facts, so take professional advice before acting.