...
NHS Pension and Annual Allowance
By Tax Accountant Editorial Team

Pensionable pay versus taxable pay: why doctors confuse the two

Pensionable pay versus taxable pay is a distinction between two figures that serve different purposes: pensionable pay is the part of a doctor's NHS earnings on which pension contributions are charged and benefits are built, while...

NHS Pension and Annual Allowance
Tax guidance should be applied to the facts. This article gives general UK tax information for doctors and medical professionals. Your own tax position may depend on records, income sources, pension figures, residence status, HMRC deadlines and previous filings.

Pensionable pay versus taxable pay is a distinction between two figures that serve different purposes: pensionable pay is the part of a doctor’s NHS earnings on which pension contributions are charged and benefits are built, while taxable pay is total earnings from the employment after pension contributions have been deducted. For most doctors neither figure equals the salary quoted in the contract, and for 2026/27 the gap between them can easily exceed £20,000.

The confusion is understandable because both figures appear on the same payslip, both are described as “pay”, and each is the right answer to a different question. The NHS Pension Scheme uses pensionable pay to set the contribution tier and to calculate pension. HMRC uses taxable pay for income tax. A third figure, the pension input amount, governs the annual allowance and is derived from neither directly.

Using the wrong one has consequences. Doctors estimate annual allowance exposure from taxable pay, assess the £100,000 personal allowance threshold from gross salary, or claim tax relief on contributions that payroll has already relieved. Each mistake is common and each produces a wrong return.

What counts as pensionable pay for a doctor

Pensionable pay is defined by the scheme regulations and the doctor’s terms and conditions, not by tax law. For a consultant, basic salary for up to ten programmed activities is pensionable, as are on-call availability supplements. Additional programmed activities above ten are not, and nor are waiting list initiative payments or fees for private patients. For a resident doctor on the 2016 contract, pay for up to 40 hours a week is pensionable and pay for additional rostered hours is not.

The figure matters twice. It fixes the member contribution rate, which in England and Wales for 2026/27 runs from 5.2% to 12.5% and is applied to the whole of pensionable pay once the tier is determined; the bands are in the NHSBSA guidance on pay and contributions. It also drives the benefit: in the 2015 Scheme a member earns a pension of 1/54th of each year’s pensionable pay.

GP partners and pensionable profits

A GP partner has no payslip. Pensionable income is the partner’s share of NHS profits as reported on the annual certificate of pensionable profits, which excludes private fees and other non-NHS income and is adjusted in ways that differ from the tax computation. Taxable income is the profit share shown on the partnership tax return. The two are prepared from the same accounts but are not the same number, and a partner’s contribution tier is set on the pensionable figure.

What taxable pay shows and how the P60 is built

NHS pension contributions are collected under a net pay arrangement. Payroll deducts the contribution from gross pay before calculating income tax, so relief at the doctor’s highest rate is given immediately and in full. The taxable pay on a payslip or P60 is therefore gross pay from that employment, including the non-pensionable elements, less the pension contribution and any salary sacrificed.

This is the source of the most expensive error. Because relief has already been given, an employed doctor must not enter NHS pension contributions in the tax relief section of a Self Assessment return. Doing so claims the relief twice. It is a mistake HMRC identifies readily, because the P60 and the claim cannot both be right, and it leads to repayment of the tax with interest and potentially a penalty. The same applies to added pension and early retirement reduction buy-out contributions taken through payroll. GP partners are in the opposite position: no payroll has relieved their contributions, so the claim is properly made on the return.

Pensionable pay versus taxable pay in a consultant’s figures

Consider a consultant in England whose pensionable pay for 2026/27 is £120,000 and who also receives £25,000 for additional programmed activities and waiting list work.

Figure Amount Used for
Gross NHS pay £145,000 Contract and mortgage purposes
Pensionable pay £120,000 Contribution tier and pension accrual
Member contribution at 12.5% £15,000 Deducted before tax
Taxable pay on the P60 £130,000 Income tax and adjusted net income

Several conclusions follow. The contribution is 12.5% of £120,000, not of £145,000. Adjusted net income starts from £130,000, which is above £125,140, so the personal allowance is lost entirely; a doctor who looked only at the £120,000 pensionable figure might have thought the position less severe than it is. And the annual allowance is tested on neither number. The new pension earned in the 2015 Scheme is £120,000 divided by 54, or £2,222, which is valued at 16 times, £35,556, before adding real growth in pension already built up. Contributions of £15,000 tell the doctor nothing about that figure, which is why the government’s guidance on the annual allowance directs members of defined benefit schemes to the scheme’s own calculation.

Where the difference catches doctors out

The tapered annual allowance uses threshold income, which is built from taxable income, and adjusted income, which adds pension growth. Non-pensionable earnings such as additional programmed activities increase taxable income without increasing pension growth, and can push threshold income above £200,000 on their own. Salary sacrifice arrangements reduce taxable pay, and in the NHS they generally reduce pensionable pay too, which lowers the pension earned for that year. For members with service in the 1995 Section, a change in pensionable pay late in a career can also alter the final salary on which those benefits are calculated.

Three figures, three purposes

A doctor’s financial position cannot be read from one line of a payslip. Pensionable pay answers how much pension is being earned and at what contribution rate. Taxable pay answers how much income tax is due and where the doctor stands against the £100,000 and £125,140 thresholds. The pension input amount answers whether an annual allowance charge arises. Advice built on the wrong figure will be wrong however carefully it is worked through.

The records that allow the three to be reconciled are the March payslip and P60 from each employer, the annual benefit statement, the Pension Savings Statement where one is issued and, for GP partners, the certificate of pensionable profits alongside the partnership accounts. Accountants 4 NHS Doctors reconciles these for consultants, GPs and resident doctors each year, because most pension tax errors begin with the two kinds of pay being treated as one.

This article is general information based on UK tax and NHS Pension Scheme rules for 2026/27 and is not advice on individual circumstances. Professional advice should be taken before acting.