...
NHS Pension and Annual Allowance
By Tax Accountant Editorial Team

When pension carry forward does not remove an annual allowance charge

Carry forward is often described as the cure for an annual allowance charge. For many doctors it is only a partial one. Pension carry forward lets unused allowance from the three previous tax years be added...

NHS Pension and Annual Allowance
Tax guidance should be applied to the facts. This article gives general UK tax information for doctors and medical professionals. Your own tax position may depend on records, income sources, pension figures, residence status, HMRC deadlines and previous filings.

Carry forward is often described as the cure for an annual allowance charge. For many doctors it is only a partial one. Pension carry forward lets unused allowance from the three previous tax years be added to the current year’s £60,000, but the amount actually available is frequently far smaller than expected. For a 2025/26 charge, one of the three years has a lower limit, and earlier excesses may already have used up what was left.

The annual allowance is the amount by which pension savings can grow in a tax year before a tax charge applies. In the NHS Pension Scheme the growth is measured by the scheme, not by the contributions paid, and it rises sharply in a year with a pay increase or a move to a higher pay point.

A doctor facing a charge is usually told that carry forward will deal with it. Sometimes it does. The purpose of this article is to explain the situations in which it does not, so that the tax return and any Scheme Pays decision are based on the real figure.

How pension carry forward works

Three rules govern the calculation. They are set out in HMRC’s manual on carry forward of the annual allowance.

First, unused allowance can be brought forward only from the three tax years immediately before the current one. Anything older is lost.

Second, the current year’s allowance must be used first. Unused amounts from earlier years are then used in order, starting with the earliest.

Third, a year counts only if the person was a member of a registered pension scheme at some point during it. Membership includes being a deferred or pensioner member, so a doctor who opted out of the NHS scheme for a period is still treated as a member.

Carry forward does not have to be claimed or reported separately. It is simply taken into account when working out the excess that goes on the tax return.

Five reasons the charge survives

One of the three years had a £40,000 limit

The standard allowance rose from £40,000 to £60,000 on 6 April 2023. Unused allowance is measured against the limit that applied in the year it arose. For a charge in 2025/26, the three earlier years are 2022/23, 2023/24 and 2024/25, and the first of those had a £40,000 limit.

A doctor whose pension grew by £38,000 in 2022/23 has £2,000 unused from that year, not £22,000. From 2026/27 onwards, all three earlier years have the £60,000 limit.

An earlier excess has already used it

This is the reason most often overlooked. If pension growth exceeded the allowance in one of the earlier years, that excess was covered at the time by unused allowance from the years before it. The allowance used then is gone, and it cannot be used again.

A doctor who had no charge in 2023/24 “because of carry forward” has less to bring forward now for exactly that reason.

The allowance was tapered in an earlier year

The annual allowance is reduced for the highest earners. The reduction applies where threshold income is over £200,000 and adjusted income is over £260,000, and the allowance can fall as low as £10,000. Where the taper applied in an earlier year, unused allowance for that year is measured against the reduced figure.

A consultant whose allowance was tapered to £30,000 in 2024/25, and whose pension grew by £28,000, has £2,000 unused from that year.

There was no scheme membership in an earlier year

A doctor who came to the UK recently, and was not a member of any UK registered pension scheme in an earlier tax year, has nothing to carry forward from that year. The same applies to the years before a doctor first joined a UK scheme.

Earlier figures have been revised

Many doctors have had their pension growth for past years recalculated as part of the remedy for the 2015 scheme changes. A revised figure for an earlier year changes the unused allowance for that year, and so changes what was available in every later year. Carry-forward workings prepared before a McCloud remedy statement arrived should be redone using the new figures.

A worked example for 2025/26

A consultant’s NHS pension grows by £82,000 in 2025/26. Against the £60,000 allowance, the excess is £22,000 before carry forward. She assumes three years of unused allowance will cover it.

Her earlier years were as follows. In 2022/23 growth was £31,000 against a £40,000 limit, leaving £9,000 unused. In 2023/24 growth was £66,000 against £60,000, an excess of £6,000. In 2024/25 growth was £52,000 against £60,000, leaving £8,000 unused.

The 2023/24 excess of £6,000 was covered at the time by the £9,000 from 2022/23, which had no earlier unused years ahead of it. That leaves £3,000 from 2022/23.

For 2025/26 she therefore has £3,000 from 2022/23 and £8,000 from 2024/25, a total of £11,000. The excess falls from £22,000 to £11,000. At the 40% rate, the charge is £4,400.

Carry forward has halved the charge. It has not removed it.

What to do when a charge remains

The excess after carry forward is the figure reported on the Self Assessment return. The tax is due by 31 January following the tax year, which for 2025/26 is 31 January 2027.

A doctor can require the NHS scheme to pay the charge, in return for a reduction in pension, where growth in the scheme was over £60,000 and the charge is more than £2,000. In the example both conditions are met. The election for 2025/26 must reach NHS Pensions by 31 July 2027.

The amount left unused after the current year also matters. In the example, nothing remains from 2022/23 or 2024/25 to carry into 2026/27. A doctor expecting another large increase next year should plan on that basis.

HMRC provides an online tool to check for unused annual allowance. It asks for pension savings figures for each year, which have to come from the scheme.

Build the four-year table before relying on it

Carry forward cannot be estimated from memory. It needs one line for the current year and one for each of the three before it, showing the pension growth, the allowance that applied, and the unused amount or excess. Each line must then be adjusted for anything used by an earlier excess.

The figures come from the scheme’s Pension Savings Statements, which show growth for the current year and the three previous years. Where a statement has not been issued, it should be requested. A doctor should keep each year’s statement and the working that was used, because the same table has to be rolled forward every year. The wider rules on the NHS pension annual allowance depend on having this table right.

This article is general information based on UK tax and NHS Pension Scheme rules at November 2026 and is not advice on individual circumstances. Professional advice should be taken before acting.