What an HMRC enquiry into private practice income may ask for
An enquiry into private practice income usually begins with a letter asking how the turnover and expenses on your return were arrived at, and for the records behind them. HMRC normally has 12 months from the...
An enquiry into private practice income usually begins with a letter asking how the turnover and expenses on your return were arrived at, and for the records behind them. HMRC normally has 12 months from the day a return was filed to open one. A 2025/26 return filed in January 2027 can therefore be opened until January 2028, well into the 2026/27 filing season.
The first request is informal and tends to be specific. It may cover the whole return, or one aspect such as motor expenses or the fees received from a single hospital. What you send, and how it is presented, shapes the rest of the check.
Doctors have one concern that most taxpayers do not: patient confidentiality. The law deals with it directly, and it is covered below.
How long does HMRC have to open an enquiry?
Under section 9A of the Taxes Management Act 1970, HMRC can enquire into a return filed on time by giving notice within twelve months of the day it was delivered. If the return was late, or you later amended it, the window runs to the quarter day after the first anniversary. The quarter days are 31 January, 30 April, 31 July and 31 October.
Once that window closes, HMRC cannot open an enquiry into the return. It can still raise an assessment if it discovers that tax was under-declared. The ordinary limit for that is four years from the end of the tax year, rising to six years where the error was careless and 20 years where it was deliberate.
What records will an enquiry into private practice income ask for?
HMRC can ask for anything it believes is relevant and reasonable for checking your tax position. For a doctor with private work, the opening letter commonly asks for:
- a breakdown of turnover by source, such as insurers, self-paying patients, hospitals and medico-legal work
- sales invoices, billing company statements and insurer remittance advices
- statements for every bank account that fees were paid into
- purchase invoices or receipts for the expenses claimed
- the basis for any apportioned cost, such as a mileage log or home-working calculation
- contracts or practising privileges agreements with private hospitals
The officer is testing two things. One is completeness: whether all fees earned reached the return. The other is whether each expense was incurred wholly and exclusively for the practice. Records that reconcile cleanly answer the first quickly, and the check then narrows to particular expenses.
Can HMRC ask for private bank statements?
HMRC can ask, and it often does where business receipts have passed through a personal account. You are entitled to question a request that looks irrelevant or excessive, and to ask why the officer needs it. If fees have only ever been paid into a dedicated account, that is a good reason to resist handing over household statements.
Can HMRC see patient records?
HMRC needs to see that a fee was earned and paid. It does not need to know why the patient attended. A formal information notice cannot require information that relates only to a person’s physical, mental, spiritual or personal welfare, a restriction set out in HMRC’s factsheet on information notices.
In practice, supply billing records without clinical content. An invoice listing a patient reference, date, fee and procedure code is normally enough. Where an appointment diary is requested to test completeness, give an extract showing dates and references with the clinical notes removed. Explain to the officer what has been redacted and why. Your professional duty of confidentiality continues throughout the check.
What happens if you do not provide the information?
If an informal request is not met, HMRC can issue an information notice under Schedule 36 to the Finance Act 2008. This is a legal demand with a deadline. You can appeal where the notice says so. There is no appeal against a notice the tribunal has approved, or one that asks only for statutory records, the records the law already requires a business to keep.
Missing the deadline brings a £300 penalty. Daily penalties of up to £60 can follow for as long as the failure continues. There is no penalty where you have a reasonable excuse, such as serious illness, and you then comply by an agreed date.
HMRC can also approach third parties, such as a billing company or private hospital, for information about you. It will usually ask your permission first, and may seek the tax tribunal’s approval if you refuse. You do not have to agree to a meeting. Many checks into professional income are handled entirely in writing.
What does it cost if errors are found?
Any additional tax is normally payable within 30 days, with interest running from the date it was originally due. HMRC’s late payment interest rate is 8% from 24 November 2026.
A penalty is then considered. It is a percentage of the extra tax, set by the behaviour behind the error and whether you disclosed it before HMRC found it:
- no penalty where you took reasonable care
- 0% to 30% for a careless error disclosed unprompted, and 15% to 30% if prompted
- 20% to 70% unprompted, or 35% to 70% prompted, for a deliberate error
- 30% to 100% unprompted, or 50% to 100% prompted, for one that was deliberate and concealed
Within each range the figure depends on how fully you explain the error, help HMRC quantify it and give access to records. A careless penalty can also be suspended for up to two years if you meet conditions designed to prevent a repeat, such as opening a separate business account or keeping a mileage log.
Take a consultant whose check finds £6,000 of home and motor costs claimed with no supporting basis. At 45% the extra tax is £2,700. If the error is careless and was found by HMRC, the penalty is between £405 and £810, and it may be suspended. The figures are modest. The time spent finding three-year-old paperwork is usually the greater cost, as HMRC’s own guidance on penalties for inaccuracies implies when it lists record-keeping first among the signs of reasonable care.
Answering the first letter well
The reply to the opening letter matters more than any later stage. Answer what was asked, in the order it was asked, with a schedule that ties each figure on the return to the documents enclosed. Do not send boxes of unsorted paper, and do not volunteer accounts or years that were not requested.
If preparing the reply shows that something on the return is wrong, say so in that reply. An error you disclose is treated more favourably than one the officer finds, and it keeps the check short. Where the problem goes back several years, a structured disclosure may be the better route, and our page on tax disclosure for doctors explains how that works.
The checks our team sees resolved fastest are those where the doctor can produce a reconciliation of fees to bank receipts within a fortnight. Building that reconciliation each year, not when a letter arrives, is the best preparation, and it is the core of our work on HMRC compliance for doctors.
This article is general information for doctors and is not advice on your individual circumstances. Tax rules change and depend on the facts, so take professional advice before acting.