What to Do When HMRC Sends a Tax Calculation You Do Not Understand
Doctors often receive HMRC tax calculations because their income record is more complex than it looks. A doctor may have one NHS salary, but the underlying payroll position can include multiple trusts, bank shifts, arrears, tax...
Doctors often receive HMRC tax calculations because their income record is more complex than it looks.
A doctor may have one NHS salary, but the underlying payroll position can include multiple trusts, bank shifts, arrears, tax code changes, student loan deductions, professional fee relief and pension adjustments.
HMRC may issue a P800 tax calculation after the end of the tax year if it thinks too much or too little tax was paid through PAYE. HMRC may also issue a Simple Assessment where tax cannot be collected automatically or where certain conditions apply.
If the calculation is unclear, the worst response is to ignore it. The second worst response is to pay it without checking the figures.
P800 and Simple Assessment are not the same
A P800 is usually an end-of-year PAYE calculation. It may show that you are due a refund or that you owe tax.
GOV.UK explains what to do if a P800 says you owe tax, including the need to contact HMRC if the amounts used are wrong. You can read the official guidance here: If your tax calculation letter says you owe tax.
A Simple Assessment is different. It is a direct HMRC tax calculation and bill. GOV.UK says you must pay a Simple Assessment bill if HMRC sends one, but you should still check the calculation. The official page is here: Pay your Simple Assessment tax bill.
First check the tax year
Start with the tax year shown on the letter.
Doctors often receive calculations for earlier years, especially where HMRC has updated payroll data late. The letter may relate to a year already covered by a tax return, or to a PAYE-only year before Self Assessment started.
Do not assume it relates to the current year.
If the letter is for a year where a tax return was filed, the position needs careful checking. HMRC’s calculation may not reflect the full return, or there may be a separate adjustment.
Check the employment income
Compare HMRC’s employment income figures with your P60s, P45s and final payslips.
Doctors who changed trusts may have more than one employment record. HMRC may also show an old employment as active, duplicate employment income, or include estimated pay.
This is common where a doctor moved between rotations or changed NHS employer during the year.
If the income figure is wrong, the tax result will also be wrong.
Check the tax deducted
The tax deducted figure is just as important as the income figure.
If HMRC has missed tax paid by one employer, the calculation may show an underpayment that does not exist. If tax deducted is overstated, HMRC may show a refund that later causes problems.
Doctors should compare the tax deducted on HMRC’s letter to the total tax shown on P60s and P45s.
A single missing P45 can change the result.
Look for professional fee relief
Many doctors claim relief for GMC, BMA, Royal College or indemnity fees.
Sometimes this relief is included in the PAYE code. Sometimes it is claimed separately. Sometimes it is included in a Self Assessment tax return.
The same cost should not be claimed twice, but it should also not be missed.
If HMRC’s calculation removes or changes professional fee relief, check whether the figure is correct.
For support with this area, see Professional Fees Tax Relief for Doctors.
Check whether Self Assessment is needed instead
A P800 or Simple Assessment may not be enough where the doctor has other reportable income.
This can include private practice income, self-employed locum work, rental income, foreign income, pension annual allowance charges, dividends, capital gains or High Income Child Benefit Charge.
If a tax return is required, the calculation should be reviewed in that context.
For doctor-specific support, see Self Assessment Tax Returns for Doctors.
Do not ignore HMRC’s deadline
If you disagree with the calculation, respond properly and keep evidence.
A doctor should not assume HMRC will correct the position automatically. HMRC’s calculation is based on information it holds. If that information is incomplete, the doctor may need to provide the missing facts.
The response should explain what is wrong and what the correct figures should be. It should not be an emotional reply saying the bill “looks too high”.
Practical example
A doctor changes NHS trust in August. HMRC receives payroll data from both employers. The old employment remains open on HMRC’s system, and the new employer uses an emergency tax code for the first month.
After the tax year ends, HMRC issues a P800 showing tax due.
The doctor checks the calculation and finds that one employment income figure is estimated. The P45 and P60 show the correct figures. HMRC updates the record and issues a revised calculation.
The key point is that the doctor checked the evidence before paying.
What records should be gathered
Before contacting HMRC or an adviser, gather the P800 or Simple Assessment letter, P60s, P45s, payslips, tax code notices, professional fee receipts, student loan plan details and any Self Assessment records.
If pension annual allowance is involved, also gather the pension savings statement.
A clean set of records usually leads to a faster answer.
Key point for doctors
An HMRC tax calculation is not automatically wrong. It is also not automatically right.
Doctors should check the tax year, income, tax deducted, tax codes, professional fee relief and whether Self Assessment is needed.
If the calculation is correct, it should be dealt with. If it is wrong, the response should be supported by clear evidence.
Disclaimer
This article is general guidance for doctors and medical professionals. It is not personal tax advice. The correct position depends on HMRC records, payroll data, Self Assessment status, professional fee claims, pension position and wider income.